So happy we found this place on our way up the coast. Some of the best pizza I have had in a long time. The Yeti was amazing and the whole staff was awesome. Would definitely recommend this place for anyone who is in the Arcata and Eureka area.
Brandon Hart
03:16 19 Jun 18
The best pizza in town. When its fresh the crust is the most delicious crust I've ever had and when it's not fresh it's still great. They have really tastey and unique options and it's super cozy inside
Leah Lehr
16:43 06 Jun 18
VEGAN PIZZA!! This is my favorite pizza place since I was a kid; their sauce is truly the best. The staff is killer, if you’ve never been, get here quick
Dani Coe
03:06 02 Jun 18
Great pizza. Friendly staff. Small bar and restaurant. I would call ahead for carry out orders. Good selection of local beer at the bar.
Steve R
18:36 16 May 18
Dutchys is great. This is a great spot to sit and have some delicious pizza. They have a Ms. Pac-Man game and great drink selections as well as TV's to follow the game. I recommend the root beer and a nice hot slice. Enjoy!
care McEwen
23:55 01 Aug 18
Dutchy's Pizza has the best pizza for the price and great service. The atmosphere is chill and the ingredients are extremely fresh. Ill be back.
Michael Cornog
04:08 16 Aug 18
Five stars just for being open after 9pm. Every other place was closed by 8 or 8:30.
Service was solid. Pizza came out hot and tasty.
Thida Ky
05:54 31 Aug 18
Love, love & love. The hot goat is amazing. Love all their pizza. Anytime I'm up here it's a must do on my itinerary. Like..... multiple must do.
glen grant
17:49 06 Sep 18
Went in to watch the Seahawks game... food was great... drinks were great... service was great... all I can say is prices were great too!!! Trevor said pull down the blinds turn up the game make yourself at home and just holler when you need me and that's exactly what I did!!! :))
Michael Noble
02:09 24 Sep 18
Good thin crust pies. East coast pizza lovers can get down here. They are similar to pauls live from New York but they have a different style. They are very nice people here and they have a nice restaurant with a bar! Some of the best pizza in Humboldt. They also have some if my favorite local wings!
James Kelly
23:44 09 Oct 18
The pizza is good and simple and they have a Ms. Pac Man cocktail cabinet. What else could you want? Beer? There's beer.
Tyler Hooker
03:01 25 Oct 18
This is the only pizza place I know of in the area that sells vegan pies, and they are delicious. We went in last night and they also happened to have my favorite beer on tap (Liquefaction by Seismic Brewing). To complete the trifecta, the front of house staff was excellent. It was very busy, and every seat was taken by customers. The servers rocked it. Due to the packed establishment there were really long wait times (a couple of large parties came in back to back) but Sam and Ray checked in with customers often and both were exceptionally friendly.
lora davis
16:42 01 Dec 18
Best beef sandwich ever!!!! And I grew up outside Chicago. Soooop good. Best pizza in town. Love the inside, used to pull up to the window in the back, lol. So glad dutchys is growing!!!
Barb Short
04:43 01 Feb 19
Baked to the right amount of time to make it crunchy. Deliciously fresh!
Adrian Haro
06:39 25 Feb 19
Good place to visit with your family great pizzzzzza and beer some video games to help with the kids and really goood wings
Alex Luna
01:56 18 Mar 19
Love Dutchy's! I've never eaten there, but buy pizzas to-go frequently. They are always ready by the time I get there to pick up, and always so tasty!
Taylor LeBlanc
16:16 31 Mar 19
My fiancé and I have lived in arcata for years, and we’ve ALWAYS absolutely LOVED Dutchy’s.
Brian Arriola
01:34 22 Apr 19
I got a BBQ chicken pizza and was gonna take a picture, but I ate it too fast. It's bomb, dude. 8/8, m8.
Garin Anderson
01:00 05 May 19
The Hot Goat is delicious (I add olives, mushrooms & peppers because I like lots of veggies on my pie) & they have awesome beer selection.
Sarah McKenzie
05:55 23 May 19
Great service and amazing pie!! I'll be back again next time I'm coming through Arcata!
Pete Kartsounes
20:18 22 May 19
Dutchy's is an incredible business to support. Their pizza is excellent - tasty crust, keeps it form, and they mix up the daily slices frequently. The Hot Goat is my personal favorite. On top of that, they are frequent supporters of the local farmers market and often use local produce for their pies! Oh, and good beer. What's not to love?
Katherine Nunes-Siciliani
05:53 12 Jul 19
This place is amazing. Great staff and unique pizza options often based off of local farmers market ingredients, this place will make you happy. I love it. Top it off with local brews on tap, and it isn't just for the kids. You wont regret your visit.
Colin Baldridge
00:03 17 Jul 19
So good and pet friendly if you sit outside. Great pizza and great prices.
Chaunte' Cross
23:36 16 Jul 19
Awesome pizza, craft beer and cool vibes! We ordered a pepperoni, bacon, jalapenos and a vege pizza. Both were Great! Love the crispy crust! Would definitely recommend this spot to anyone up in Arcata, McKinleyville, Trinidad or Eureka! So glad we found Dutchy's Pizza!
Bone Lee
16:34 24 Aug 19
The best pizza in Arcata hands down...
Diamond T Love
15:58 27 Oct 19
Bomb Pizza. Bottom line. As well, great wings. Great beer on tap. Great service.
Zion Paragon
07:02 04 Dec 19
Greeat food and super fun atmosphere! Highly recommend! Had the goats cheese and honey pizza and OMG it was so good i didnt get any pictures 😍
Vanessa Ggoff
10:07 12 Dec 19
Best pizza in the area in my opinion great price and good service, have never had any problems here. And always has customers.
agariomaster10
20:50 27 Jan 20
Excellent pizza, great beer and a wonderful atmosphere. This is the place to find your Liverpool FC support group, watch the game in good company. Delicious spicy honey for sale as a fancy condiment.
Desirae Inman
15:11 21 Feb 20
I love pizza. So, naturally, I've eaten pizza all over Humboldt county. When I went to Dutchy's for the first time I loved them. I went a few weeks later and fell in love again. Now, I go basically every week. Everyone is friendly, and the pizza has the best crust in town. Every day they change a couple of slices and they have actually good vegetarian options!!
Shay Konradsdottir
22:54 11 Mar 20
Great pizza beer and fresh renovation. Looks great.
capn zach
03:27 01 Oct 16
What a great pie thanks
Jeff Mckenzie
01:59 13 Sep 20
Had the Hot Goat and it was incredible!!! Service was top notch. Was a little disappointed orginally that they did not want/allow substitutions on their pies because I would've loved to add some kind of meat to the order but it worked out incredibly. Will definitely come back if I am ever in the area.
Timothy Hulvalchick
18:06 21 Mar 21
Really friendly staff. I’ve never been disappointed by this pizza 🍕 hot goat is 🔥⭐️
Mo Diddly
03:39 11 May 21
The honey added was great, never had it before
Aicha DeJesus
00:15 21 May 21
Delicious new york style pizza, just like we remember from our time living there. Delivery was timely and the staff were great- professional and polite. Would definitely eat here again if given the chance.
Samantha Kiehne
02:37 23 May 21
Very friendly and reasonably priced
Bernadette Carlson
18:00 08 Aug 21
I got the veggie pizza. The pizza is as great as mentioned in reviews. Worth stopping here.
Archit Pandey
21:26 11 Sep 21
Just stopped by and once again was blown away by the quality of food and excellent customer service. Sausage, cherry peppers, onion on a rich red sauce was beyond satisfying.
Chris H
00:51 04 Dec 21
Super friendly staff, great pizza
Tyler Downing
21:17 16 Jan 22
One of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The crust was crispy and thin. Good amount of tomato sauce. The cheese melted perfectly. Nice edge crust with some garlic butter I think. A great pizza.I got a little flustered over the difference between a medium pizza and a 12-inch pizza. I learned there is no universal "small," "medium," "large" with pizza. A medium could be whatever-inch the restaurant makes it. My social skills have declined in the last decade and more rapidly in the last few years.Dutchy's has a 12-inch and then a larger size (18-inch?). It's great pizza. The staff are friendly and helpful.I got a half cheese and half pepperoni.
J G
22:05 05 Feb 22
I love eating here and the staff have always been friendly.
Jeffrey Sterling
23:54 16 Feb 22
Yuuuuummm!! I love the Hot Goat with extra spicy honey, soo good!!
Kellie Fike
03:23 18 Feb 22
High quality of taste pizza here.
Love the feeling about this restaurant, hope to live close by so I could visit this place regularly.
Antonio D
05:24 05 Jun 22
Lovely, thin crust, NY style pizza. Delicious. Small, but nice selection of local draft beers and ciders.
Harris Fogel
07:21 17 Jun 22
Pizza is always on point. Delicious crust and toppings are epic! The specials run are decent priced as well. Dutchy is the nicest guy to come from Jersey since the Boss! Thanks guys!
Drew Mentzer
16:12 07 Jul 22
Great pizza and barbecue chicken, place has character and worth the visit. Has two monitors showing sports, and has outdoor seating.
Cyril Oberlander
04:19 23 Sep 22
Best pizza in town easily.
From the crust, to the sauce, the cheese and the toppings, all is top tier.
This is the level of pizza you would expect from NYC, and we are so lucky to have it here.
Nicholas Lubitz
23:02 01 Oct 22
We love Dutchy’s! Yummy pizza and fresh local ingredients for their caprice salad! I don’t even watch sportsball, but it’s always fun to post up at the bar and hang with those that do! Plus, two-player Mrs. Pac-Man!
Portia S.
19:06 27 Dec 22
Very attention to my babies. They were making a mess and loudly roaring their baby roars watching a basketball game (college). They had more than two baby seats which seems hard to find in this community. Patrons were very understanding. Not 5 stars because the dough could've used some salt, but otherwise very tasty. Babies approved!
Sugiura Masato
18:38 09 Feb 23
This was literally the best Philly cheese steak I've ever had. I love that this place is so unassuming and chill. Did I mention the Philly? Fuggin off the hook. Good beer, great wings but o.m.g. the Philly is ridiculous. I almost ordered a second one because of how amazing it was......Philly, fuggin Philly. I'd drive from sac town for this thing.
Sean Brooks
21:34 14 Mar 23
Stopped in here for a slice. We got 2 slices of pepperoni and 2 slices of cheese. Service was nice and efficient. Pizza was exactly what I was looking for. If you’re looking for a classic New York style greasy slice this the place to go!
Evan Fonfa
17:58 18 Mar 23
OFF THE HOOK PIZZA! The dough is cooked perfectly OMG I could keep on eating! Addictive yumminess!! A hidden treasure in Arcata. A MUST GO TO!! Delicious food, fast, great service 😋
Saalav C
04:36 30 Apr 23
I went in to try a Chicago Italian beef for the first time because of a good friend of mine in Chicago told me they're super good. I don't know if this is what they're like in Chi, but holy smokes was that a good sandwich! I will definitely be back for it.
Carrina Hanson
21:16 04 Jun 23
I knew this pizza would be delicious when I noticed they had garlic powder on the table. Garlic powder and chili flakes, you need nothing more.
Hello Jose
03:25 11 Jul 23
I love Dutchy's! The Hot Goat pizza is amazing! All of their sandwiches are delicious and everything is very reasonably priced for the quality. The owner is a really nice guy and the staff is always attentive. Support this business!!
katagunda
17:12 02 Aug 23
Pizza here is perfectly old-fashioned and satisfying. The sauce is incredible and the slices of pepperoni are the affordable, delicious greasiness you dream about! However if you are in the mood for vegetarian fare they have plenty of options like the Hot Goat, and even offer vegan cheese right on the main menu. There's an old school Pac Man video game and a couple of picnic tables outside. The indoor seating can get a little loud but I know some people are into it so they can watch sports or bring their family. Definitely recommend!
C N
23:22 19 Oct 23
Favorite pizza. The hot goat is an absolute go to.
Great people and a fun place to watch sports.
Megan Maier
01:54 07 Apr 24
A hidden gem. I passed by this spot for years and finally tried it. I've eaten there several times now and highly recommend it. If you want something a little different try the "Hot Goat" or for a more traditional flavor the "Veggie" is awesome. In addition, I think they have the best beer prices in town and they carry Redwood Curtain Sticky Fingers so that's a big plus too.
Will Dower
03:45 27 May 24
Pleasantly surprised at how delicious this pizza was! Not much to look at from the outside, but the service was great and fast. The cheese had such a nice flavor and the perfect amount of chewiness. We got a large pepperoni, olive and sausage pizza… great crust. Not too thick not too thin, right amount of crisp and chew. Got it to go drove 15 minutes home and it was perfect. There’s nothing I would’ve changed about this pizza! Kame as a recommendation from the checker at Murphy’s market lol… Stoked to find a new-to-us great pizza place!
Ruby Christine
17:24 09 Jul 24
We love Dutchy's!! Great place to hang out, excellent service, and of course the Hot Goat is bomb. My favorite. Highly recommend!
Gretchen Miller
02:28 16 Jul 24
Love this place. They have great pies and slices along with cold brews and the games. But the Philly Cheese Steak is great. Be back soon
Jason Miller
04:59 16 Jul 24
Great location, great pizza, and reasonable prices. I'll take it!Popped in with a pup the other day, and it turns out this place is also very pet-friendly, so that's a plus. There's water provided, and a dog leash cleat. Dutchy himself even came out and gave the dog a treat!The lunch special is a pretty good deal, especially given that you can apply the discount to beer. Two slices of pizza and a beer? Man it's hard to beat that.Interior is nice, clean and open. They have TVs that will have a game on, usually. But this place doesn't feel like a sports bar. Great place to sit and have a bite, or take advantage of the patio on a nice day.
Wes Temby
15:49 13 Jun 18
I went there because the website said they have Italian Beef Sandwiches. When I went in they said they took it off the menu because no one was buying any. What is wrong with you people? Because you all have horrible taste, I can't get Italian Beef.
Tony Persico
18:37 16 Jul 18
Tasty selection of specialty pizzas, sandwiches, and other goodies. They have a nice indoor seating area with a bar and TV's spread throughout. If it were cheaper I would come way more often.
Daniel Plainview
04:33 18 Jan 19
Very tasty pizza! Ordered take out but the inside looked nice, they had a fireplace and several TVs
Olivier Glaser
08:40 01 Mar 19
Great pizza! The hot goat is my favorite 😍
Tony Schneringer
07:16 06 Apr 19
Just a nice little pizza bar. This isn't a 4 star pizza to me but for the area it's definitely the best around I think.
Eric DeLong
19:38 21 May 19
Not bad but not the best pizza in Arcata. The amount of food you get for the price is definitely worth it though.
Spencer Huckins
23:27 05 Jul 19
I enjoyed a slice of cheese pizza which I consider the gold medal standard for judging purposes I found the pizza to be tasty nice cheese flavor nice tomato paste style tomato sauce and decent crust. Somewhat reminiscent of school cafeteria Pizza in a good way like fond memories.
Stewart Richlin
01:37 30 Jul 19
Sweet spot. Beer on tap pizzas alright but cheese steaks rock
dirtgirl 73
08:34 26 Sep 19
The vegan pizza is soo good (they use follow your heart cheese!)
Honestly just missing more dough options (I really want it with a thicker crust just once) and a veg meat options would be cool.
Kev H.
06:44 02 Jan 20
Very yummy pizza, great flavors and fast service. 💯
Mariah Ziemer
01:11 17 Nov 20
great vegan pizza options. Amazing crust. Dutchy himself came out to inform us that they were out of marinated garlic and we wouldn't have the full margherita experience. He delivered the news as if he was telling us there were complications with a loved one's surgery. Very impressive service.
Steve
18:08 06 Sep 22
We were on vacation, and I told my daughter to just pick a random place that we had never been to before, and this was our destination. The food was very good!! The pizza was brought to us shortly, and the wings took a while but were very delicious. The service was awesome. The owner was there and he was very personable. I would definitely recommend that place again.
Theron Sanders
20:49 04 Sep 23
